TMCnet Feature Free eNews Subscription
March 26, 2024

Is SIEM outdated? Why Traditional SIEM is Dead



When SIEM was first introduced to the world of computing by Mark Nicolett and Amrit Williams of Gartner (News - Alert), it revolutionized the way businesses and IT professionals approached systems security. By merging information storage/analysis functionality with real-time monitoring and notification of security events, SIEM strategies offer protection from both vulnerabilities caused by internal system errors and outside malicious actors.



However, many businesses find that their SIEM dashboards are struggling to maintain system security with the efficiency they once did. The global technological ecosystem is a very different place in 2021 from what it was in 2005.

With increasingly cloud-based infrastructures, internet and user traffic at levels, and new service-oriented architectures, can a traditional SIEM approach effectively monitor and protect against modern security threats? This is where the Stellar next generation SIEM platform comes into play, offering a comprehensive solution to the challenges of cybersecurity.

The Evolution of SIEM

The emergence of SIEM in the early 2000s marked a turning point in cybersecurity. Visionaries like Mark Nicolett and Amrit Williams of Gartner laid the groundwork. SIEM amalgamated information storage, analysis, and real-time monitoring, offering a shield against internal errors and external threats. It streamlined security operations, empowering businesses to respond swiftly to potential breaches.

The Downfall of Traditional SIEM

However, traditional SIEM's glory days seem to be fading fast. Despite its early promise, traditional SIEM is struggling to cope with the demands of contemporary cybersecurity. The reasons behind its downfall are manifold, ranging from scalability issues to a lack of intelligence and poor analytics capabilities. Let's look into the shortcomings that have rendered traditional SIEM obsolete.

?Scalability Woes: A Barrier to Effective Security

One of the fundamental flaws plaguing traditional SIEM is its poor scalability, particularly concerning correlation. While these systems excel in log collection and aggregation, they falter when it comes to correlating vast amounts of data effectively.

Using case-based correlation rules and log filtering demands meticulous fine-tuning to minimize the strain on the correlation engine. Despite vendors' claims of scalability, the practical efficacy of these systems falls short, jeopardizing organizations' security posture.

?Intelligence Deficiency: The Achilles' Heel of SIEM

Contrary to popular belief, traditional SIEM systems' intelligence quotient is alarmingly low. Out-of-the-box rules primarily revolve around compliance requirements or basic security practices, lacking the sophistication needed to detect modern-day threats.

Pattern recognition rules are antiquated, often failing to identify malicious activities within the network. This shortage of intelligence leaves organizations vulnerable to advanced cyber adversaries, showing the inadequacy of traditional SIEM in today's threat.

?Limited Scope: Restricting Security Beyond SOC

While traditional SIEM solutions find their niche within Security Operations Centers (SOCs), their relevance outside this is debatable. Their prowess in alarm-based event management dwindles when it comes to event searches and reporting, diminishing their appeal beyond the confines of SOC environments.

The inability to provide comprehensive event searches and analytical insights restricts their utility in addressing broader security concerns across diverse business domains.

?Steep Learning Curve: A Barrier to Adoption

The complexities of traditional SIEM systems entail a steep learning curve, which poses a barrier to adoption. While basic functionalities may be relatively straightforward to understand, exploring advanced features requires expertise and experience.

Organizations often rely on a handful of specialists to manage and maintain these systems, accentuating the resource-intensive nature of traditional SIEM deployments. The reliance on a select few experts necessitates the challenge of sustaining these systems in the long run.

?Maintenance Nightmare: Struggling to Stay Afloat

As organizations scale their SIEM deployments to meet security needs, the maintenance overhead escalates proportionally. Mission-critical functions dependent on SIEM for alerting and monitoring amplify the importance of maintenance practices.

However, as the system grows in complexity, so does the burden of upkeep, draining valuable engineering resources. The incessant demand for maintenance poses a challenge, often overshadowing the purported benefits of traditional SIEM solutions.

?Poor Analytics: Falling Short of Expectations

Despite touting themselves as analytics providers, traditional SIEM systems often fail to deliver on this front. Analyzing large volumes of data and deriving meaningful insights necessitates robust analytical capabilities, which traditional SIEM systems lack.

Scalability constraints impede their ability to process, store, and analyze data effectively, relegating them to a subpar status in analytics. While exceptions exist, the majority of SIEM solutions struggle to meet the analytical demands of modern cybersecurity operations.

?Poor ITSM Capabilities: Bridging the Divide

Integrating SIEM with IT Service Management (ITSM) tools poses a challenge due to inherent limitations in ITSM capabilities. The reliance on third-party integrations often results in one-way communication, hindering seamless collaboration between SIEM and ITSM platforms.

This unidirectional flow impedes the tracking and management of security incidents, propelling operational inefficiencies. The disjointed nature of SIEM-ITSM integration shows the need for a more cohesive approach to security and service management.

?Poor Automation: Complexity Compounded

Traditional SIEM ecosystems are rife with complexities, which are worsened by their poor automation capabilities. Reliance on third-party automation and response tools further complicates security, introducing additional layers of integration and management overhead.

This fragmented automation ecosystem undermines the efficiency and efficacy of security operations, prolonging response times and increasing the risk of oversight.

Contextual Insights: Understanding the Why

Context is the cornerstone of effective threat response, and observability platforms excel in providing contextual insights into security events. By enriching event logs with contextual information, such as user behavior and system dependencies, these platforms empower security teams to make informed decisions quickly.

The contextual depth offered by observability platforms transcends the superficial alerts generated by traditional SIEM systems, enabling organizations to differentiate between benign anomalies and genuine threats.

?Streamlined Management: Simplifying Complexity

Many organizations find the complexity inherent in traditional SIEM deployments a deterrent. Observability platforms such as Stellar Cyber offer a streamlined alternative, simplifying security management through intuitive interfaces and automated workflows. By abstracting away security operations, these platforms empower organizations to focus on strategic initiatives rather than mundane maintenance tasks.

The simplicity and efficiency of observability platforms redefine the user experience, democratizing access to advanced security capabilities.

?Adaptive Intelligence: Evolving with the Threats

Unlike traditional SIEM systems, which rely on static alert thresholds and predefined use cases, observability platforms leverage adaptive intelligence to detect and mitigate threats dynamically. By harnessing AI and machine learning algorithms, these platforms continuously analyze vast amounts of data, identifying patterns and anomalies indicative of potential security breaches.

This approach to threat detection enables organizations to stay one step ahead of cyber adversaries and adapt to evolving threats in real-time.

?Cost-Efficiency: Maximizing ROI

Traditional SIEM deployments are notorious for their excessive costs, both in terms of upfront investment and ongoing maintenance. In contrast, observability platforms like Stellar Cyber offered a more cost-effective alternative, with scalable pricing models and reduced operational overhead.

By leveraging cloud-based infrastructure and managed services, organizations can optimize their security budget while maximizing ROI.

Conclusion

The era of traditional SIEM is drawing to a close, making way for observability platforms. As organizations struggle with the complexities of modern cybersecurity threats, the need for adaptive, intelligent, and cost-effective security solutions has never been greater.

By embracing the capabilities of observability platforms, organizations can navigate these threats with confidence, safeguarding their digital assets and preserving their competitive edge in an increasingly hostile environment. The demise of traditional SIEM paves a new era of security innovation, where visibility, intelligence, and agility converge to redefine the boundaries of cybersecurity excellence.



» More TMCnet Feature Articles
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. [Free eNews Subscription]
SHARE THIS ARTICLE

LATEST TMCNET ARTICLES

» More TMCnet Feature Articles